Theodore J. Furry, 1975-76*
Joseph A. Sherman, 1976-77*
Lantz Welch, 1977-78*
Jerome T. Wolf, 1979
Bruce G. Heavner, 1980
Darrell Havener, 1981*
Willard B. Bunch, 1982*
R. Lawrence Ward, 1983
Robert C. Welch, 1984
Sandra L. Schermerhorn, 1985
Fred Wilkins, 1986
Wm. Dirk Vandever, 1987
Norman O. Sanders, 1988*
Reggie C. Giffin, 1989
James C. Wirken, 1990
John C. Dods, 1991*
J.D. Williamson, Jr., 1992
Thomas G. Kokoruda, 1993
James Bartimus, 1994
William T. Session, 1995
Walter R. Simpson, 1996
Ann Mesle, 1997
John S. Johnston, 1998
Cindy Reams Martin, 1999
P. John Brady, 2000
Stephen B. Millin, Jr., 2001
John M. Edgar, 2002
Sylvester James, Jr., 2003
Jay D. DeHardt, 2004
James P. Frickleton, 2005
C. Patrick McLarney, 2006
Charles W. German, 2007
Gregory M. Bentz, 2008
Rebbecca Lake Wood, 2009
Thomas Bender, 2010
James A. Heeter, 2011
Nancy E. Kenner, 2012
Rod L. Richardson, 2013
W. Perry Brandt, 2014
Scott S. Bethune, 2015
Russell S. Jones, Jr., 2016
Daniel E. Blegen, 2017
Nikki E. Cannezzaro, 2018
Nathan A. Orr, 2019
Athena M. Dickson, 2020
Samuel M. Wendt, 2021
Bill Martucci, 2022
Phyllis A. Norman, 2023
* Deceased
** Re-elected to succeed himself
† Resigned upon election to circuit bench